BLOG

The difference between ribbon mixer and other mixers

Date 2026.01.26
Share

Ribbon mixer is recommended to use during the production of water soluble fertilizer, it is mainly because of its special process of water-soluble fertilizer production and the technical advantages of ribbon mixers.

The special factors and requirements during the mixing process for the water soluble fertilizer production.

1.The raw material of Water-soluble fertilizer are mostly fine powders, which are easy to generate dust, thus need the closed mixing equipment.

2.It requires extremely high nutrient uniformity (especially micro-nutrients). Uneven mixing will affect fertilizer efficacy a lot.

3.Those raw materials may have significantly different densities, and ordinary mixing can easily cause them to separate layers.

4.Some formula require the addition of liquid nutrients or binders, which will require the mixing machine is capable of “solid-liquid mixing” and preventing clumping.

The core advantages of the ribbon mixer are fully meet the above requirements.

1.The ribbon mixer uses internal and external counter-rotating spiral ribbons to propel materials to make them tumble up and down and left and right within the drum, thus can achieve a mixing uniformity of over 99%.

2.It is Suitable for mixing materials of different densities, also can avoid stratification well.

3.The enclosed structure design combined with the dust removal interface can effectively prevents dust from overflowing.

4.Its structure can push the material towards the discharge port to result in a high cleaning rate (residual amount <0.1%)

Below are the comparison among ribbon mixer and other mixers.

NameWorking principleDisadvantages of ribbon mixers in water-soluble fertilizer production
Double shaft mxierTwo shafts with paddles  rotate in opposite directions, to shear and scatter the mateirals b fast RPMHigh risk of crystal breakage, The high paddle RPM and strong shearing force easily break the crystalline particles of water-soluble fertilizer; cleaning is  more complicated.
Drum mixerThe drum rotates to mix the materials by gravity.Low mixing intensity, difficult to guarantee mxing uniformity especially for the addition of trace elements, dead zones exist
Spiral mixerThe material is lifted from the bottom to top  and sprinkled by the central spiralPoor mixing uniformity, easy to stratification, incomplete unloading resulting in significant residue, many dead zones of sedimentation at the bottom

During the production of water soluble fertilizer, even you already are using ribbon mixer, some process optimization is still a necessary to follow.

1.Sequence of feeding raw material: feed the macro-elements such as urea/DAP first, then trace elements.

2.Mixing time: it is better to determine the mixing time by some trial test in order to avoid over-mixing or under-mixing, which can lead to uneven mixing or crystal breakage. Usually we recommend to mix 5-10 minutes and uniformity(CV) can reach ≤3-5%.

3.Cleanliness for formula: thorough cleaning is a must during formula changes to prevent cross-contamination.

Ribbon mixers already become the first choice for water-soluble fertilizer production because of its high-efficiency/dead-angle-free mixing, adaptability to different gravity material, and compatibility with solid-liquid additives. we recommended to select a ribbon mixer based on its production capacity and formulation characteristics.

Zhengzhou Safi Machinery Co.,Ltd can work out full process solutions and machines for producing water soluble fertilizer, suspension liquid fertilizer, gel liquid fertilizer, organic fertilizer and compound NPK fertilizer.

Interesting, feel free to contact me

SAFI MACHINERY

www.safimachinery.com

Whatsapp: +86 15238391768

Get A Free Quote

Quick Quote

Our professional team will reply you as soon as possible.
Online Whatsapp Message Email